Homemade Thousand Island Dressing Recipe - Rachel Cooks® (2024)

FAQs

What is the Flavour of Thousand Island? ›

Praise Everyday Thousand Island Dressing is a tomato flavoured sauce spiced with paprika that adds flavour to veggie salads, seafood and burgers.

The Thousand Island dressing combines ketchup, mayonnaise, sweet pickle relish, vinegar, minced onion and garlic. In contrast, the French dressing is composed of olive oil, vinegar, mustard, ketchup, sugar, and paprika, among other seasonings. The former is mayo-based, while the latter relies more on vegetable oil.

From Thousand Islands to the Waldorf-Astoria

That story says that Waldorf-Astoria owner George Boldt and his wife, Louise, were on their boat when their chef realized he forgot the dressing for the salad. So he made a dressing with the ingredients he had on the boat and this became Thousand Island dressing.

What does Thousand Island dressing taste like? Thousand Island dressing is fairly sweet. The ketchup offers sweetness, as does the bit of added sugar. (You can leave that out if you like a more tangy dressing.)

If you look at Russian dressing and Thousand Island dressing side by side, they're pretty similar. And that's because both sauces have a mayo and ketchup base. However, while Thousand Island dressing includes pickle relish, making it a bit sweeter, Russian dressing tends to include horseradish to give it a little kick.

Thousand Island dressing is an American salad dressing and condiment based on mayonnaise that can include olive oil, lemon juice, orange juice, paprika, Worcestershire sauce, mustard, vinegar, cream, chili sauce, tomato purée, and ketchup or Tabasco sauce.

And while the horseradish arguably makes Russian dressing a little more flavorful, Thousand Island tends to be the secret sauce of choice for burgers, perhaps because the horseradish would just get buried beneath the other elements anyway. Russian and Thousand Island have lots of other cousins, too.

While there are a lot of overlapping ingredients, there are also some key differences between these two iconic slathers. To start, both are mostly made from a mix of mayonnaise and ketchup, but generally, Russian dressing is a little spicy while Thousand Island tends to be on the sweeter side.

Is Big Mac Sauce the same as Thousand Island Dressing? The two are similar, but they have different ingredient ratios. Also, Thousand Island dressing is made with ketchup and diced onions. Big Mac sauce doesn't use either of these ingredients.

Thousand Island Dressing can last anywhere from 3-8 months in your fridge. If unopened and properly stored, it may even last until the manufacturer's intended expiry date on the package, which is usually a year from the manufacturing date.

Is burger sauce the same as Thousand Island? ›

Is burger sauce the same as Thousand Island? The two share a lot of similarities in ingredients and color, but they're not exactly the same. Burger sauce really just a mix of condiments like mayo, mustard, ketchup, and relish with a few extra flavorings thrown in.

This type of dressing is very versatile, so don't just confine it to a lettuce-based salad. Use it in place of tartar sauce for fried fish, as a condiment for potatoes or other vegetables, or as a spread on your favorite sandwich.

And at the top of that list? Caesar dressing. Made up of mayonnaise, cheese, salt and oil (and all too often, anchovies), Caesar tends to be one of the least healthy options out there. Those ingredients cause it to be high in both saturated fats and sodium.

Ranch Dressing

The ranch is hands down America's most beloved salad dressings. It is made from a number of ingredients such as buttermilk, mayonnaise, mustard, garlic, onion, chives, salt, and pepper.

Thousand Island Ingredients: It's mixture of mayonnaise, sour cream, ketchup, sweet pickle relish, red onion vinegar, sugar, garlic, and salt and pepper. All ingredients are combined by hand to make a perfect, thick, and creamy dressing, dip, or sauce.

The answer is no… but they are similar. Both of the condiments have a creamy consistency and include pickle relish. But, McDonald's Big Mac Sauce includes vinegar and has a bit more pickle relish in it than Thousand Island dressing.

The two are similar, but they have different ingredient ratios. Also, Thousand Island dressing is made with ketchup and diced onions. Big Mac sauce doesn't use either of these ingredients. Both are tasty, and if you're looking for a homemade Thousand Island dressing recipe, you can find mine here!

To start, "thousand island dressing" is also reffered to as "secret sauce" by many fast food locations (notably, usually without tomatoes), though this would be most accurate to Ed's sauce, as it's contents are literally a secret.